Judge refuses to order vaccinations
Calgary Sun
http://www.calgarysun.com/news/alberta/2010/12/03/16411281.html
By Kevin Martin, Calgary Sun
Last Updated: December 2, 2010
Vaccinations aren’t “essential” medical treatments, a family court judge has
ruled in refusing a Child Welfare request to order inoculations for four kids.
Judge Stephen Lipton, in a written decision released Thursday, said while the
vaccinations are preferable, it wasn’t in his power to order them.
Child Welfare had applied for a ruling to have the siblings immunized despite
their parents’ decision not to allow the treatment.
But Lipton said the four children, ranging in age from one to 12, weren’t at any
present risk so no court intervention was warranted.
“I find that on the facts of this case the vaccinations proposed by the
caseworker don’t fall within the definition of ‘essential’ (in the
legislation),” Lipton said. “The children are healthy and none of them are at
imminent risk of serious harm.”
Lipton noted the dangers of not getting immunized would expose the children to
the risk of contracting illnesses which could cause brain injury or death.
The mother refused allowing vaccines for her children while the father suggested
herbal medicines would be effective.
kevin.martin@sunmedia.ca