Exodus myth
Religion
What is a people? A people generally shares a way of life, a language, a
food, a geography. There is no Jewish language. Shlomo Sand stumbles proudly in
English, while of course many of the people in the audience were Jews speaking
English. Food the Israelis have--stolen from the Palestinians—and still you must
say that there is an Israeli people. But they are not the Jewish people. They
are Israeli people, and the Palestinians are Palestinian people. Both made by
Zionism.
The Zionist project began inventing
the idea of a Jewish people in the 1870s as a reflection of other nationalisms.
The Zionists turned to the Bible for the foundational myth. The biblical myths
are taught in Israeli schools from before children are taught mathematics and
language--taught about the biblical associations of Jews to this land. But
the Exodus is a complete myth. “As a historian, I try and predict the past.
I’m not a prophet.” And what are the true predictions of the past: at the
supposed time of the Exodus, the Egyptians also controlled Canaan. The kingdom
of David and Solomon was not a kingdom at all, but a small settlement around
Jerusalem.
[2009] At NYU, devilish Shlomo Sand predicts the
Jewish past and pastes the Zionists
Sand.....comes to the conclusion that Jewish exile is also a myth, and that the present day Palestinians are far more likely to be the descendants of the ancient Semitic people in Judea/Canaan than the current, predominantly Khazarian-origin, Ashkenazi crowd (p.135). [2011] The Wandering Who?: A Study of Jewish Identity Politics by Gilad Atzmon