is a semi-anonymous Allopathic
seems to spend most of his time on medical politics--in other words: suppressing
the truth, alternative medicine, and any criticism of Allopathy, on Wikipedia. He is a master of the spurious
reason for deleting pages, text, and links he doesn't like. A fine example,
right before your eyes, of the 100 year Allopathic
suppression of non-pharma medicine & health/disease knowledge.]
Here on the page he created called
he deleted 4 quotes by anti vax people [ref].
Even after he had put a reply to each one.
Harassment of alt med editors using RFCs
One way Midgley can get at non-Allopathic editors (outnumbered
20 to 1) is to creat RFCs (ref,
ref). Then numerous medical people come in vote against.
Even though whale has the orginal books on line [See:
vax books] Midgley is using spurious reasons
to delete links to those books.
Richard Shulze [ref]
Autism epidemic [Deletion page]
Making out vaccine critics are
cranks/insane ['Anti-vaccine is a pejorative term.]
This vaccinator created the
page on Wikipedia so he could control that page and also make out anti-vaccine
people are cranks (the term, like cranks, is pejorative), which he demonstrated
by linking the page to the crank page
[ref]. Anti-vaccinists is
a term that fell out of use for this reason. Now he is attempting to
delete by merger Beddow
National Anti-Vaccination League, into this page.
So you can see this page
National Anti-Vaccination League vanish into
Bear in mind they DELETED a very similar page called Vaccine critics
 which, get this, is now directed to his
Anti-vaccine page! Check it out
You can see his thinking: I write as someone who
treats a small number of psychotic patients, and therefore might come from
someone psychotic or a group simulating psychosis for their own amusement.
(John's writing is not very closely similar, one may have an idée fixée without
being mad even in a lay sense)).[ref]
[ref] Psychotic is
Allopathic for forbidden thinking/beliefs [See:
Please also see here (emphasis added) the use of "anti-vaccinationist" as a
pejorative term "For your work against quacks, viz. anti-vaccinationists
and others, I award you this picture of Sir William Osler and three
The Spurious reasons.
Richard Schulze (naturopath) [deletion
ref]. [Richard Shulze is one of the best Natural Healers. See
Dr Richard Shulze]
Delete unless verified - it has had a verify tag and comments on it since
January, and no action has occurred, and it is now high in the Google ranking
for this subject.
13:41, 3 April 2006 (UTC)
Deletion page [There is one but they still deny it due to the vaccine
This article has a name which gives a clue to its troubles. If it had been
called "Autism (Incidence)" or "Autism (Incidence and reporting)" then it could
have been a discussion on a sub-topic of
Autism. As it
is, it is a brawl, hath little of structure or consensus and is not - looking at
the long history in the talk page - getting better over time. There is actually
a topic worth writing an article about, but that isn't the topic and this isn't
the article, and it never will become that from here. Delete, and start from
scratch, and get someone to volunteer to write it who is noted for NPOV, before
the rest of the editing process gets going.
22:49, 5 April 2006 (UTC)
Deletion page. [Most notable independent scientist on
thimerosal, the vaccine ingredient. See
"Another not-a-biography page with disreputable
references, toxic hyperbole, buzz phrases "50% Mercury by weight". It is
Thimerosal controversy being re-written along with conspiracy theorising,
Gulf War syndrome and
WP:OWN by the
usual author, Ombudsman. An academic Chemist with not a single published paper
referred to in the article. Not notable, at least, on nothing like this basis.
Not WP:BIO Not
good." 'Speedy DELETE
00:56, 11 March 2006 (UTC)
Robert S. Mendelsohn [Deletion
page. Most notable anti-vaccine medical doctor of 20 century. See
"This is not a useful page about an interesting person. The authors are
mainly noted for efforts to present poorly reasoned attacks on vaccination in a
wide and inappropriate variety of articles. The Quackwatch commentary linked
from the page is informative."--Midgley
01:37, 22 January 2006 (UTC)
page. See here.]
"Delete This has the appearance of an advertisment. The names seem
too close to be coincidental, and the site link and book link seem likely to be
closely related to the author's benefit. The coloured light stuff is quackery,
but that of itself is not suggested to be the reason for deletion."
02:43, 1 March 2006 (UTC)
Deletion page. [Rare ex-government
critic of MMR vaccine]
"POV non WP:BIO. Not encyclopaedic. There are very
very many retired civil service doctors in England and the only thing adduced
about him is that he was to have been one witness in a trial which will not
occur since the legal aid board determined it had no chance at all of success.
Basically this is yet another attack page on immunisation presented as a
biography - possibly we should decide that these are speedy delete candidates.
10:27, 7 March 2006 (UTC)
Keep - this is just another attempt by Midgley to remove information
that is inconvenient for his opinion. Midgley has been on Wikipedia a short
time, but has a consistent record of personal attacks, borderline vandalism,
malicious sockpuppetry and impersonation. --Leifern
13:05, 12 March 2006 (UTC)
page. Notable anti-vaccine medical man.
"nn (there are currently 100 000 doctors practicing in
the UK of whom more could be gleaned from The Medical Register than is here -
"he was a doctor who worked with two other doctors, and did not use a particular
treatment. His father also was a doctor and did not use that treatment". The
links are to a clonelet of the author's whale.to website which has been
determined by RFC to be not
WP:RS - the site
in question was established after whale.to ceased getting links from WP. This is
one of many nn articles generally lacking in interest and
WP:V and by
User:Whaleto in pursuit of his
09:07, 5 April 2006 (UTC)
Alan Cantwell. [One of the main bogey men to Allopathy, see
Midgley is behind this one.
Assorted text and link deletions
Removing text re measles
 Deleting whale.to link
Here he has removed thimerosal info
Another editor taking exception to be labelled anti-vaccine
Midgley 3 hrs
Spurious reason for deleting Nexus article:
 1 minute reader reason for deleting National Anti Vaccine League!
Deletion 'by merger' attempts
He tried to delete the main medical anti-vaccinator of the last century
, Now he is attempting to delete by merger
National Anti-Vaccination League, into a page he created with his POV
What you wrote in my user discussion page violated WP. I trust
that you will not do so again in the future. And I expect no
"Invisible Anon" vandalism. Thank you.
User:jgwlaw, but take it to RFC if you won't take
Midgley 04:23, 4 April 2006 (UTC)
- Is that a threat? Are you a self-proclaimed guardian
of Wikopedia? Your "advice" was insulting and incorrect.
- Further, you may not like what I and others have
written on Breast Implants, but what we have stated is
correct. Both I and the other author have either
epidemiology or scientific background. What we have
stated is not what it appears you like to call "pseudo
science", unless you call anything you disagree with
See user page. Signing comments is not regarded as optional.
Midgley 07:55, 4 April 2006 (UTC)
Fine. I intended to sign. I will sign this.
Jgwlaw 12:36, 4 April 2006 (UTC) And you need to know that I
will not toleate your following me around with insults.
Jgwlaw 12:36, 4 April 2006 (UTC)